Home / Resources / SEO consultant or SEO agency: which is right for you?

SEO consultant or SEO agency: which is right for you?

Both can work well. The right choice depends on your business, your team and how you like to work.

Written by Tiffany Fowler, independent SEO consultant in Adelaide. Last reviewed 20 November 2026. LinkedIn

What an agency offers

Agencies bring a team, with specialists in areas such as content, development and paid search. They can run large projects, provide cover when someone is away and offer several services under one roof. The trade-off is that your account may be handled by junior staff, and priorities can be shaped by the agency's processes.

What a consultant offers

A consultant is usually more senior and closer to the work. You speak to the person doing the thinking, and advice is tailored to you rather than to a package. Costs tend to be lower because there is less overhead. The trade-off is that one person has limits on capacity, and you may need other suppliers for tasks such as development or design.

Questions to help you decide

  • Do you want a long-term partner who knows your business, or a team to deliver a large project?
  • Do you already have developers, designers or writers?
  • How much hands-on time do you want from the person leading your SEO?
  • Is flexibility more important than a single supplier for everything?

My view

I have worked in agencies and in-house, and I believe both have a place. I work as a consultant because I care about bottom line results and like being close to clients. If I think an agency is a better fit for what you need, I will tell you.

Questions

Can a consultant handle a large website?

Often, yes, particularly in a strategic role with your developers doing the build. Some very large projects need more hands than one person can offer.

What if my consultant is unavailable?

Ask how they handle holidays and illness. A good consultant has a plan and tells you in advance.

Want to talk about your search results?

Email me a few lines about your business and website. I will tell you honestly whether SEO is likely to be worth it for you right now.